Is it safe to vacation in Mexico?
Written by: Rough Writer Staff | 12 Mar 2009
Students must decide if a trip to sunny Mexico is worth the risk of a travel warning and rising violence with Spring Break right around the corner.
With over 100,000 teenagers and young adults traveling over the border and into Mexico for Spring Break each year, according to US Department of Travel, the “increase in violence” including “Mexican and foreign bystanders be[ing] injured or killed in violent attacks in cities across the country” and “dozens of U.S. citizens be[ing] kidnapped across Mexico” may cause some students to rethink this destination as a Spring Break party place.
As explained in the US Department of Travel’s Alert Mexican drug cartels are battling not only between each other, but also with local police to secure narcotic trafficking routes along the United States Mexico Border. The attacks are said to resemble, “small-unit combat, with cartels employing automatic weapons and grenades.”
Arizona’s universities have all issued a warning similar to the Department of Travel’s. University of Arizona Dean of Students, Dr. Carol Thompson, wrote, “The University of Arizona Dean of Students Office strongly advises students to avoid travel to Mexico at this time and during Spring Break.”
Some students aren’t worried
However, some students such as John Paul Devers, a junior at University of Arizona, feel comfortable enough to continue with their plans to travel to Mexico. “My parents own a condo in Rocky Point, it’s for tourists and I know my way around,” says Devers, who will travel to Mexico for the third year in a row for spring break.
Devers is not incredulous of the news reports telling of violence and dangers. “I see it as a real problem,” Devers admits. “It kind of scares me, but I’m going to treat this like it’s any other trip, only maybe be a little bit more cautious.”
Devers, along with other students in Arizona and across the nation cannot ignore the truth of the violence, but he does not see it as a direct threat. “I don’t think they are overreacting, I just know how to stay safe,” says Devers, who is excitedly counting down to his long-awaited vacation. “I’m just not going to go looking for cocaine or hookers.”
Devers’ view of the threat the violence poses to tourists is similar to that of Doreen McDonald, owner of Your Personal Travel Service in Prescott. “I would not hesitate to send a group of college students to Puerto Penasco,” says McDonald.
Puerto Penasco (Rocky Point)
Puerto Penasco, also known as Rocky Point, the most accessible beach for Arizona students, and according to McDonald is miles from the core of the cartel violence, and has increased security since the travel alert was issued.
“It’s only 65 miles south of the border, heavily traveled, and feels safer. Drug Lords aren’t patrolling there,” says McDonald.
“More than 1,800 people have been killed in the city since January 2008.”
Despite McDonald’s confidence in the safety of Rocky Point, she says that she has seen the affect of the alert and rising violence on Mexico’s tourism. “We did not have t he bookings for Mexico this year,” says McDonald, comparing this year to the past. “Let’s put it this way, I’ve had about three for spring break this year, about 1 percent of other years.”
Ciudad Juarez
Both McDonald and the Department of Travel advisory specifically mentioned the violence in Ciudad Juarez, where as the travel alert states, “more than 1,800 people have been killed in the city since January 2008. Additionally, this city of 1.6 million people experienced more than 17,000 car thefts and 1,650 carjackings in 2008.”
Ciudad Juarez lies 417 miles from Puerto Penasco, which is Devers’ destination and in McDonald’s opinion the safest tourist spot in Mexico. This distance is greater then that from Phoenix, AZ to Los Angeles, CA, or a six hour drive.
Arizona Attorney General Terry Goddard says safety concerns around Puerto Peñasco are at a “far lesser degree” than other areas such as Nogales, Juarez and Tijuana. “They are worlds away,” says McDonald comparing the “red border zone” or dangerous cities, and Puerto Peñasco.
Some are staying away
Some students see things in quite a different way than Devers though. College student Danielle Baughman says, “If there weren’t warnings there, I would definitely consider going there, but with all the stuff going on, I wouldn’t choose to go there right now.”
This, along with a post from student Bobby1 on an azcentral.com news article about Spring Breakers ignoring the warnings show that for some, at least, the warnings have hit home. “Mexico for Spring Break? Why even chance it,” he says.
For the students who do choose to travel to Mexico, the U.S. Department of Travel offers a list of things to “Know Before You Go.” This list includes Mexican laws on required documentation, drug and alcohol consumption, driving laws, and firearm and weapon laws.
“If I could counsel tourists on anything, it would be on the importance of proper documentation and keeping up with those changing laws,” says McDonald.
In addition to this, the U.S. Department of Travel’s notification emphasizes the importance of traveling in numbers, staying in well lit areas, and staying in places that are well populated with tourists and security.









Why doesn’t anyone write the “positive” about Puerto Penasco (Rocky Point) as the main part of an article, instead of the horror story about certain parts of Mexico, and then, after people are sure they will die, there are a couple of small paragraphs that say this bad news does not include Rocky Point?
Maybe if I offer a FREE condo, someone from the press would come see for themselves what the situation is on this town.
As the author of this article, I’d like to say that I think that ignoring the danger is the surest way to end up a victim of it.
I think that ignorance is the greatest danger, and honestly that’s why I wrote this story, in hopes to find out how much of what we hear is media hype, and how much is true.
I hope at least that this article helped emphasize the truth of violence, while allowing us to realize where the threats are and are not.
I also want to add that I am currently writing this from a condo on the beach of Rocky Point, and I haven’t felt in danger yet.
Not to mention this is some of the most fun I’ve had doing hands-on reporting.
I am agree with Bretty.
Its true that there is little safety to roam around in Mexico and that is why such incident happen.
But every person should responsible for his/her own life and every place has white and black sides.
I am pity sad for such accidents.
If precautions are take then number of such incidence can be decreased.
I live in Cancun and watch Fox News on occasion, it was kind of strange to see the way O’reilly et al were trying to manipulate things that happened in the border towns and say that Cancun was dangerous as well – When it obviously isn’t.
Two police guys got shot here – this isn’t a new thing and has been going on for years, the fact that they were involved in crime and corruption probably was the factor that lead to their deaths – but this has been ghoing on for years. Cancun is no more dangerous today than it was 3 years ago. However this incident was blown out of all proportion.
I think the media were trying to scare people from traveling to Cancun for Spring Break – so they stayed in the states and spent money in the resort towns there – thus stimulating the economy. If this was the case it makes sense really – but don’t spread lies about other places thats completely wrong!!
Hi Betty. I would like to take you up on your offer of a free condo for my wife and 2 children and report back on this site. Let me know. Thanks.
i agree with Riviera Maya Resorts..the U.s. in trying to manipulate people so they spend more of their money in the U.S., how come they dont talk about all crimes goin on in America..Mexico is the same like everywhere else there is good and bad parts..they only way you can killed is if you are involved in the drug industry.!
In these stark economic times most of us find ourselves cutting expenses and learning to do without vacations, travel and expensive homecare. The new website Host and Care offers a creative solution to the economic slump. Host and Care helps match students to international or domestic homes, and vacationers to fellow vacationers willing to exchange homes or host visitors.
Leave your response!
Advertisement for Guidance Helicopters
Pages
Sections
Websites of Interest